Dai Sijie is a wonderful storyteller... [It is] so well done, in such a swift and uncompromising way, that the reader and author and characters feel the simple astonishment of having survived ... the end of the tale is beautifully conclusive and satisfactory
- A. S. Byatt, Guardian
This shy, complex novel, which speaks its concerns so quietly, remains a forceful lament, infused with incident and dramatic storytelling
- Julian Evans, The Daily Telegraph
It exercises a subtle and persuasive charm... Its evocation of the distant world of devoted Chinese scholarship and dying artistry is lovingly and enchantingly done
- Alan Massie, Scotsman
An elegant, polished, scholarly piece
- Kate Saunders, The Times
Evokes the past with all the eerie clarity of a dream, its outlines blurred but every tiny, telling detail extraordinarily alive. Anyone in search of a brief history of China would do well to begin right here
- Margaret Hillenbrand, Financial Times
A rich and poetic novel
The Big Issue
Sijie has produced another cunning literary confection, blending history, romance, a long-lost manuscript and the magic of the Orient... Sijie can still draw readers into his elegant web
Mail on Sunday
Dignified and scholarly.
- Claire Anderson Wheeler, The Irish Times