This book is an impressive accomplishment and seems destined to become the new standard reference for scholars looking to engage debates over the sacraments in the early Reformation. Burnett's profound facility with the primary sources is richly on display throughout the monograph. Her sophisticated analysis yields fresh insights about the subject matter which will inform future studies for many years to come ... Debating the Sacraments belongs on the shelf of every student of the Reformation, and every theologian interested in sacramental theology and the nature of ecclesial authority.
David Luy, International Journal of Systematic Theology
Burnett's focus is on the period when Protestant sacramental theology became hot topics in the 1520s. Her approach is chronological as well as wide-ranging ... This gives the book an authoritative, reference-like power that will make it the place to turn to for all future forays into this tangled topic. Her approach is also unique among other treatments of this topic since her net is wider and more nuanced than what we have had before.
Donald K. McKim, Journal of Ecclesiastical History
In the current volume, Amy Burnett has managed to tackle one of the theological debates most fraught with danger and to bring new clarity to the early stages of the intra-Protestant debate over the Lord's Supper. This is no mean feat...in the future no one should dare write anything on the role of Lord's Supper in the early Reformation without taking seriously this outstanding piece of research. It is remarkable scholarship and a fitting tribute to the other historian able to do this kind of work, her Doktorvater, the late Robert Kingdon.
Timothy J. Wengert, United Lutheran Seminary, Comptes Rendus