In sum, the book is an important contribution to the current debate on the PoS. It is highly recommended to scholars that have a specific interest in PoS research, and may be suggested to others. Furthermore, the link between PoS theory and historical linguistics makes the book (and, generally, the literature on PoS typology) a good buy for libraries interested in Indo-European and Semitic linguistics.
- Luca Alfieri, in Studies in Language 37(2): 425-434, 2013,
My evaluation of the volume is strongly positive. Besides the very high quality of every contribution, I particularly appreciated the continuity of the discussion in which the assorted parts fit well together: every essay is functional to and helps a better comprehension of the others. Even the order in which the papers have been presented helps the reader to follow the thread of discussion, despite the differences of topics and theoretical frameworks of the papers.
- Germana Olga Civilleri, Roma Tre University, on Linguist List 22.2283, 2011,
These articles were originally published in Studies in Language 32:3 (2008).