This is a scholarly, well-documented account, and much of the book is given over to colorful specific accounts that make it utterly fascinating reading, suitable for a large audience.
P. T. Smith, CHOICE
This is an impressive book, the product of considerable research and informed by the mastery of the relationship between crime and society, the history of policing and the development of criminal law, which has made Emsley a leading authority in his field.
A.W, Purdue, Times Higher Education
this volume is recommended to any historian interested in the social history of the two world wars. Its engaging style and readability, as well as the final chapters that explore the question of criminal behavior and military justice in the British armed services after 1945, will appeal to all those interested in twentieth-century British history, to which it makes an original and important contribution.
Jessica Meyer, The American Historical Review
Until now no one has carried out a systematic study of crime in Britain's mass armed forces. With this exceptionally well-researched and very readable study, Clive Emsley has now filled this gap in the historiography ... it deserves a wide readership.
Gary Sheffield, History Today
This is a well-written and researched academic text on the law and the British Armed Services which is both readable and accessible to the non-specialist in law or criminology, while still providing a detailed and insightful discussion, which may very well become a standard text on the subject.
Dr Phylomena H. Badsey, Policing
inspired by this author's graceful handling of such a compelling historical phenomenon
Andrew Muldoon, Reviews in History
Clive Emsley's book offers and overview of the pattern of enforcement of military law since 1914 suggesting, in particular, that civilian criminal experience, with some important qualifications, has been replicated in the armed forces since 1914.
Gerry Rubin, Journal of Law and Society
Throughout the book, the discussion is detailed and concise with regular use of researched cases serving to support, and complement, the analysis.
Daniel Packham, The Howard Journal of Criminal Justice
This is a well-written and researched academic text on the law and the British Armed Services which is both readable and accessible to the non-specialist in law or criminology, while still providing a detailed and insightful discussion, which may very well become a standard text on the subject.
Policing
rich material ... offers a basis for exciting new ideas and methodologies for projects interweaving crime and military history
Eloise Moss, English Historical Review