... excellent volume ... provide[s] a fresh perspective both on Scottish and on imperial history. They seem to have been more tightly interwoven than used to be thought. Both Scots and English should take note.
Bernard Porter, History Today
This excellent collection considers the significance of Scotland for the empire and the empire for Scotland and challenges scholars of both Scotland and imperialism to consider that country's experience within wider debates in imperial studies
Kathleen Haldane Grenier, Journal of British Studies
The authors and editors make a real effort to eschew triumphalism; they are alive to the dangers of parochialism and, at a time when scholars are embracing the postcolonial trend towards transnationalism, of adopting a potentially inapposite national framework
Valerie Wallace, Victorian Studies
This volume is sure to be an essential text for many undergraduates, researchers and the much courted "informed amateur" ... a testament to the health of imperial studies of Scotland and Scottish studies of empire
C.M.M. Macdonald, Annual Bulletin of Historical Literature