The Panthay uprising ought to be a textbook case of how a religious minority can be othered and ethnic tension mishandled. Therein lies the significance of this new edition of <i>The Panthay Rebellion</i> ... a balanced account ... a cautionary tale
- Wong Chee Meng, Mekong Review
Valuable reading for persons interested in the economic and political history of minorities in China . and in particular the history of Muslims in China'
- Eva Goldschmidt, H-Net
A thought-provoking, sophisticated study
Journal of Asian Studies
Compelling, I would strongly recommend it
- Beth E. Notar, Pacific Affairs
A book that should be read
Journal of Chinese Studies
A major contribution to the historiography of nineteenth-century China and of Chinese Islam
American Historical Review