Honorable Mention, WORLD Magazine's Understanding America Book of the Year 2021.
WORLD Magazine
What distinguishes Phillips's work is his ambitious attempt to marry mind and matter, to insert material culture into a study of perceptions, which could have easily relied merely on close readings of textual evidence. Phillips ventures far beyond the usual cadre of theoretical work informing Civil War scholarship, drawing on a wide and interdisciplinary body of work to shape his ideas about temporality, prophecy, and materiality. His omnivorous approach to intellectual influences is particularly welcome considering the traditional reticence in the field to use theory as a grounding for primary source research. The result is a major contribution to the cultural history of the Civil War, a smart, dense, and ambitious book, tackling important questions and offering rich answers.
Yael A. Sternhell, Journal of the Civil War Era
Jason Phillips has produced an exceptionally creative and original work exploring how Americans envisioned impending sectional conflict in the antebellum period. Looming Civil War: How Nineteenth-Century Americans Imagined the Future is about more than the Civil War itself; it is a meditation on the nature of historical imagination, demonstrating brilliantly how historical time extends into the future, or into multiple potential futures that shape and constrain the possibilities for action in the present ... Phillips's argument constitutes a major contribution to time studies, the currently burgeoning field of scholarship concerned with the cultural history of temporality. Phillips also pays special attention to material culture ... Looming Civil War is a magnificent accomplishment, a strikingly original and beautifully written remembrance of futures past, those imagined and those made real.
Thomas Allen, American Historical Review
This fine book demonstrates convincingly that antebellum Americans were far from unaware of the carnage to come, and that someactively embraced the prospect of civil war.Phillips marshals his evidence from contemporary diaries, letters, and published texts with admirable skill. The book overflows with insights about the importance of material culture to his subjects and the capacity of new technologies, such as telegraphy and the railroads, to affect how Americans regarded the future.
Robers Cook, Journal of Southern History
Much more than a study of how antebellum Americans confronted the possibility of a civil war, this is a discussion of how men and women conceived of the future and their own ability, as individuals, to affect what would happen to them and their country... Some readers may hear echoes of The Great War and Modern Memory in Phillips's narrative, a blending of history and literature with an imaginative interpretation of language use and material culture in his effort to uncover people's sense of their place in the world and their attempts to understand what was happening to them amidst the crises of rapid, threatening change and, eventually, war.
Christopher J. Olsen, Journal of Social History
Phillips goes far beyond myth busting in this superbly crafted book. By exploring how religion, material culture, and notions of time shaped Americans' prognostications, he weaves diverse forecasts into a sophisticated study that makes an excellent contribution to Civil War historiography... This smart, engaging book will resonate with readers living in unpredictable and portentous times.
Michael E. Woods, Journal of American History
Looming Civil War is a big, bold book... a sparkling addition to the literature... It is a book that should not be missed.
Joseph W. Pearson, Civil War Book review
a groundbreaking history about how Americans viewed the impending crisis. In it, he introduces the reader to a new way of examining history, namely how Americans anticipated the future for themselves as well as for the country at large. He overturns myths about the Civil War ... Phillips examines diaries, prophecies, dreams, art, literature, and sermons by a wide variety of Northerners and Southerners ... Highly recommended.
L. M. Hauptman, CHOICE