Benedictow's book is highly recommended. It is well written and accompanied by many helpful maps and tables of data.
STUDIES IN MEDIEVAL AND RENAISSANCE TEACHING
The thoroughness and precision of [Benedictow's] research are admirable. [...] Opens a treasure trove of correct information. There is no doubt that [the book] should be acquired by all university libraries.
FIFTEENTH-CENTURY STUDIES
Every library that covers population studies, epistemology, or medieval history should have a copy of Benedictow's book.
POPULATION STUDIES & DEVELOPMENT
A book which should be on every Late-Medievalist's bookshelf. It is packed with valuable and well-considered accounts. ... A wonderful compilation of data which will be widely used for many years to come.
MEDIEVAL ARCHAEOLOGY
[This] remarkable, engrossing and controversial study is the first to assemble and synthesize historical data from every region in which the Black Death wrought havoc. [...] An immense and entirely breathtaking feat of scholarship...and a moving quest to account for a cruel phenomenon.
TLS
[This] magisterial account mixes demographic research, meticulous reading of the chronicles and modern bacteriology.
THE GUARDIAN
The author...has achieved a Herculean task in reviewing a very large part of the literature on the pestilential disease or set of diseases that afflicted Europe from 1346 to 1353.
THE MEDIEVAL REVIEW
A valuable addition to the historiography of the Black Death. Highly recommended.
CHOICE
Ambitious and contentious.
ENGLISH HISTORICAL REVIEW
Those looking for a vast compendium of local data will not be disappointed.
SPECULUM