Brink's book is a triumph. It is valuable because it is the most complete and comprehensive articulation of responsibility and excuses, and because every chapter contains insights as to particular excuses themselves
Philosophical Review
I cannot help but marvel at Brink's accomplishment. I cannot think of another writer who has so systematically worked through so many moral and legal intricacies. It has a rightful place on the shelf of all theorists interested in responsibility
and the criminal law
Philosophical Review
David Brink has been writing about responsibility for almost two decades. He has now written a splendid book, Fair Opportunity & Responsibility, that sums up and expands the themes that he has been so fruitfully pursuing. It is an excellent blend of theory and practical arguments for law reform. It is also stunningly polite, fair-minded and humane. ... Every criminal law scholar should read Fair Opportunity & Responsibility
Criminal Law and Philosophy
David Brink has done an extraordinary job identifying, defending, and applying what might be called a master principle of culpability [fair opportunity]. He has written a wonderful book, full of nuance and philosophical sophistication
Criminal Law and Philosophy