The textual analyses of fragments and corresponding commentary are insightful and informative, rendering this volume an essential tool for scholars and advanced students working in these texts.
Daniel M. Gurtner, Crestwood, Kentucky, Religious Studies Review
this work provides a thorough, cautious, and well-balanced assessment of the evidence for two no longer extant works ... Grounded in previous scholarship and presented in a well-organized fashion, this work offers the reader an accessible and comprehensive overview of the relevant data for understanding each of these lost Gospels. ... Both readers well acquainted with these lost Gospels and those who have never previously encountered these works will greatly benefit from the present edition.
Matthew Goldstone, Catholic Biblical Quarterly
a very helpful publication, which deals effectively and thoughtfully with what is a complicated and difficult subject about which much has been written and a variety of sometimes convoluted theories presented ... [this is] a volume whose appearance can only enhance discussion of a variety of subjects in the study of early Christianity
James Carleton Paget, Journal of Ecclesiastical History
An excellent edition, highly recommended
Matthew V. Novenson, Journal for the Study of The New Testament
This welcome and long awaited addition to a valuable series has been written by one of its two co-editors, Andrew Gregory. His thorough and meticulous work on the Jewish-Christian Gospels is an exemplary study that will now supersede the previous works written by A. F. J. Klijn. ... Gregory is to be congratulated on his significant achievements.
J. K. Elliott, Novum Testamentum